Please wait...

Search by Term. Or Use the code. Met a coordinator today? Confirm the Identity by badge# number here, look for BallotboxIndia Verified Badge tag on profile.
सर्च करें या कोड का इस्तेमाल करें, क्या आज बैलटबॉक्सइंडिया कोऑर्डिनेटर से मिले? पहचान के लिए बैज नंबर डालें और BallotboxIndia Verified Badge का निशान देखें.

Search Results, page {{ }} of (About {{ header.searchresult.count }} Results) Remove Filter - {{ header.searchentitytype }}

ज़िला कनेक्ट

करें अपने ज़िले को मज़बूत, जुड़ें ज़िला कनेक्ट से.
Join Your District, get latest news, listen to podcast, Check and Submit Stories that matter, near you on the Map.
सीधे अपने ज़िले से जुड़ें, जानें, देखें क्या नया हो रहा है, ऑडियो पॉडकास्ट सुने या आपके आस पास आपसे जुड़े मुद्दों के बारे में नक़्शे पर जानें, या उन्हें सबमिट करें.

Oops! Lost, aren't we?

We can not find what you are looking for. Please check below recommendations. or Go to Home

Jagdish Bhagwati on demonetization is so wrong that you might loose faith.

Demonetization (Currency Ban) in India- All you need to know about.

Demonetization (Currency Ban) in India- All you need to know about. Opinions & Updates

ByRakesh Prasad Rakesh Prasad   {{descmodel.currdesc.readstats }}

Originally Posted by {{ || descmodel.currdesc.parent.user.first_name + ' ' + descmodel.currdesc.parent.user.last_name}} {{ descmodel.currdesc.parent.user.totalreps | number}}   {{ descmodel.currdesc.parent.last_modified|date:'dd/MM/yyyy h:mma' }}

Screen Grab from the interview on NDTV Dated Dec-13-2016

It was tough to watch the whole 21 minutes, never been a big fan of Mr. Bhagwati, have read him mostly with Mr. Panagaria. Still had some illusions which are now broken, shattered. 

Lets break down the interview and see if we can make any sense.

Transitional Loss

Yes we all agree 87% of cash value in the economy getting defunct and new set of notes printed is a loss. What was the point of coining a new term smugly. Does it take out the whole printing, circulating, logistics and opportunity cost loss. You failed to put any number to this transitional loss, which is very unworthy of an economist of any repute.  It all sounded like

Well when you drop a huge rock on a goat, and as you know goats bleat and rocks are really heavy, and by the way stones falling on your head can really hurt, and this is not any ordinary stone its an Indian rock. So I will call it a "Brain Bowl Mushification".

Whats the point Mr. Bhagwati?

Abrogation to the obligation to pay argument.

None, You return the old currency note and get a new one back- Wow its wrong at so many levels and so tough to believe that even after a month you didn't care to actually look at whats going on, but smugly made this statement.

Sir, ask the people in line who are not getting their own money, note or no note. There is a limit imposed on how much money one can take out it ranges arbitrary with bank to bank based on the amount of cash there.

Its even after depositing your own money, you are NOT getting your own money back. And I consider the obligation to pay applies to all the money in bank or in my pocket. 

This is a violation and a grave one since its coming from a sovereign nations government.

The value of the note is bound by those few words written on it, people perceive their own worth based on those notes, make plans, budget their months. If you bend or break those rules for whatever reasons there goes the trust, and when there is no trust on the words from the Reserve Bank of India's Governor himself whats the whole point of wasting money holding elections, making laws at first place.

Why parliaments sit every few months and why these documents are printed, whats the point of anything called rule of law and validity of contracts?

I know something about Indian Constitution and Amendment 1, I have taught it for 2 years.

You didn't just say that did you? did you just invoke emergency laws into this argument. Of course sir, Government has army it can take everything if it wants.

The country where you are sitting after a huge level of deliberation created a second amendment, simply to counter such an incursion. I think NRA should listen to your buffoonery on constitution for a fitting reply.

Yes there are laws and clauses and yes constitutional "experts" like you (pun intended) will try to find their own definition off the disparate pieces taken out of context. But its so wrong at so many level to see the rot, when an economist is using emergency argument to justify demonetization.

Cash in Almirah, and Real estate transactions with Black Money.

Sir, looks like you have lost any connect with reality. Do you really think people in 2016 have cash lying around in their Almirah, or is it too much of movies off 70s. You failed to give any numbers here again, and promptly equated cash with black money, or non tax paying money.

Which is wrong and troubling, specially making it tough to keep watching this interview is the way you are smugly saying it.

Sir black money in Real estate is such a hammered and beaten to death argument that no one even buys it in India. In 2012 yes, in 2016 ? Can you provide figures, real estate deals are few most closely watched deals in India by tax department.

Not sure if you were talking about India or Jackson Heights? or still living in a notion of India of 70s. 

If Almirah money and Real estate is your argument for burning 87% of Indian currency in circulation.

God bless us, your university and students.

I'm not rushing in with some sort of pronouncements and have studied it deeply.

No Sir, You have no idea what you are talking about. You might want to show me your PHD and Commendation, my argument - Sir that's nothing, anyone with basic intelligence can grind through it and sit where you are at the age of 82 making buffoonery of every constitutional or economic principal.

Cash was lying around, now it will come into circulation -

What? people were transacting in cash and its lying useless non-transaction at the same time. Isn't it like cake and eat it too argument. And as per your own argument people are just exchanging money, so money is going back into the same system, or you have plans to hold off the money by government muscle in banks?

Again no real figures of cash under mattress or in almirah.

Sir one massive factor, economists like yourself fail to mention or include into this whole multiplier theory of yours - Cash transactions too have a multiplier effect. It might be the best system available for India which deals in low value transactions. Transactions with such lower denominations that building a secure, efficient cashless system might not even be feasible. 

And if you can't do something end to end, why do it at all. And isn't it India's biggest problem? Doing something which might sound right, half heatedly and the failing monumentally.

I will end it at this. Will see if I can meet you in person and get a confirmation in person that it was you and you really meant it.

See you around sir, you keep the mint in the arguments alive.

Rakesh Prasad

Rookie Economist, Tinker, Founder

Attached Images

Related Videos
Related Audio
Leave a comment for the team.
Subscribe to this research.
रिसर्च को सब्सक्राइब करें

Join us on the latest researches that matter.

इस रिसर्च पर अपडेट पाने के लिए और इससे जुड़ने के लिए अपना ईमेल आईडी नीचे भरें.


{{ }}@{{ survey.senton }}
{{ survey.message }}

How It Works

ये कैसे कार्य करता है ?

start a research
Follow & Join.

With more and more following, the research starts attracting best of the coordinators and experts.

start a research
Build a Team

Coordinators build a team with experts to pick up the execution. Start building a plan.

start a research
Fix the issue.

The team works transparently and systematically fixing the issue, building the leaders of tomorrow.

start a research
जुड़ें और फॉलो करें

ज्यादा से ज्यादा जुड़े लोग, प्रतिभाशाली समन्वयकों एवं विशेषज्ञों को आकर्षित करेंगे , इस मुद्दे को एक पकड़ मिलेगी और तेज़ी से आगे बढ़ने में मदद ।

start a research
संगठित हों

हमारे समन्वयक अपने साथ विशेषज्ञों को ले कर एक कार्य समूह का गठन करेंगे, और एक योज़नाबद्ध तरीके से काम करना सुरु करेंगे

start a research
समाधान पायें

कार्य समूह पारदर्शिता एवं कुशलता के साथ समाधान की ओर क़दम बढ़ाएगा, साथ में ही समाज में से ही कुछ भविष्य के अधिनायकों को उभरने में सहायता करेगा।

How can you make a difference?

Do you care about this issue? Do You think a concrete action should be taken?Then Follow and Support this Research Action Group.Following will not only keep you updated on the latest, help voicing your opinions, and inspire our Coordinators & Experts. But will get you priority on our study tours, events, seminars, panels, courses and a lot more on the subject and beyond.

आप कैसे एक बेहतर समाज के निर्माण में अपना योगदान दे सकते हैं ?

क्या आप इस या इसी जैसे दूसरे मुद्दे से जुड़े हुए हैं, या प्रभावित हैं? क्या आपको लगता है इसपर कुछ कारगर कदम उठाने चाहिए ?तो नीचे फॉलो का बटन दबा कर समर्थन व्यक्त करें।इससे हम आपको समय पर अपडेट कर पाएंगे, और आपके विचार जान पाएंगे। ज्यादा से ज्यादा लोगों द्वारा फॉलो होने पर इस मुद्दे पर कार्यरत विशेषज्ञों एवं समन्वयकों का ना सिर्फ़ मनोबल बढ़ेगा, बल्कि हम आपको, अपने समय समय पर होने वाले शोध यात्राएं, सर्वे, सेमिनार्स, कार्यक्रम, तथा विषय एक्सपर्ट्स कोर्स इत्यादि में सम्मिलित कर पाएंगे।
Communities and Nations where citizens spend time exploring and nurturing their culture, processes, civil liberties and responsibilities. Have a well-researched voice on issues of systemic importance, are the one which flourish to become beacon of light for the world.
समाज एवं राष्ट्र, जहाँ लोग कुछ समय अपनी संस्कृति, सभ्यता, अधिकारों और जिम्मेदारियों को समझने एवं सँवारने में लगाते हैं। एक सोची समझी, जानी बूझी आवाज़ और समझ रखते हैं। वही देश संसार में विशिष्टता और प्रभुत्व स्थापित कर पाते हैं।
Share it across your social networks.
अपने सोशल नेटवर्क पर शेयर करें

Every small step counts, share it across your friends and networks. You never know, the issue you care about, might find a champion.

हर छोटा बड़ा कदम मायने रखता है, अपने दोस्तों और जानकारों से ये मुद्दा साझा करें , क्या पता उन्ही में से कोई इस विषय का विशेषज्ञ निकल जाए।

Got few hours a week to do public good ?

Join the Research Action Group as a member or expert, work with right team and get funded. To know more contact a Coordinator with a little bit of details on your expertise and experiences.

क्या आपके पास कुछ समय सामजिक कार्य के लिए होता है ?

इस एक्शन ग्रुप के सहभागी बनें, एक सदस्य, विशेषज्ञ या समन्वयक की तरह जुड़ें । अधिक जानकारी के लिए समन्वयक से संपर्क करें और अपने बारे में बताएं।

Know someone who can help?
क्या आप किसी को जानते हैं, जो इस विषय पर कार्यरत हैं ?
Invite by emails.
ईमेल से आमंत्रित करें
The researches on ballotboxindia are available under restrictive Creative commons. If you have any comments or want to cite the work please drop a note to letters at ballotboxindia dot com.

Code# 5{{ }}

ज़ारी शोध जिनमे आप एक भूमिका निभा सकते है. Live Action Researches that might need your help.